The year-end bonus run is the payroll cycle most likely to produce a genuine problem, because it combines an unusual amount, an unusual timing, and an employee population paying close attention to their net pay.
The withholding choice is the visible question. The consequences that actually cost money are the deposit threshold, the retroactive overtime, and — for 2026 — the earnings-code coding that determines whether your Form W-2 reports qualified overtime correctly.
Two
...