Reviewed by Charlie Bross, Principal · Payroll Training Center
An employee has been out on workers' comp for months, the position needs to be filled, or a layoff is coming that includes their job. Can you end their employment? In most states, yes: being on workers' comp does not make someone impossible to fire. But terminating an employee while on workers compensation is one of the highest-risk employment decisions a small employer makes. It combines workers' comp retaliation law, the FMLA, the ADA, final pay rules and benefits continuation, all in one decision.
This checklist is written for the HR and payroll people who carry the decision out. It covers the legal checks before the decision, the payroll and benefits steps after it, what to tell the carrier, and the file you should be able to produce if the decision is challenged. It is not legal advice. Have employment counsel review any termination of an employee with an open claim. For the bigger picture, see our workers' comp hub.
Nearly every state prohibits firing or otherwise discriminating against an employee for filing a workers' comp claim. Examples:
What these laws protect is the claim, not the job. An employer can generally still terminate for a legitimate reason unrelated to the claim. The question a judge or agency will ask is whether the real reason was the claim. Before you act, be able to answer these with documents:
Workers' comp leave often runs at the same time as FMLA leave, and the injury may also be a disability under the ADA. Check both before terminating. Our guide to the FMLA, ADA and workers' comp overlap covers how the three interact.
State laws may add protections, including state leave laws and disability laws that cover smaller employers than the ADA's 15-employee threshold.
Once the decision is made, payroll's deadlines start. They are set by state law and differ widely. Some states require final pay at the time of discharge; others allow the next regular payday. California, for example, requires wages due on discharge to be paid immediately (Labor Code 201), with waiting-time penalties for willful delay, and treats earned vacation as wages to be paid out at termination. Our guide to final paycheck rules lists state deadlines.
Workers' comp adds a few twists:
COBRA. Termination of employment (other than for gross misconduct) is a COBRA qualifying event for employers with 20 or more employees, giving up to 18 months of continuation coverage. The employer must notify the plan administrator within 30 days of the qualifying event, and the administrator then has 14 days to send the election notice (29 U.S.C. 1166). Many states have mini-COBRA laws for smaller employers. Our guide to COBRA administration for payroll has the full process.
Two workers' comp complications:
Premium arrears. Employees on unpaid leave often stop paying their share of health premiums because there is no paycheck to deduct from. Under the FMLA, an employer can recover its share of premiums paid during unpaid FMLA leave if the employee fails to return, but not if the reason is the continuation, recurrence or onset of a serious health condition or other circumstances beyond the employee's control (29 CFR 825.213). An employee who does not return because of the work injury will usually fall in the exception. Leave paid under a workers' comp or other temporary disability plan is not unpaid leave for this purpose. Get counsel's advice before billing a former employee, and check state deduction law before taking anything from a final check.
Notify the carrier or claims administrator in writing on or before the termination date. Include:
Termination usually does not end workers' comp benefits by itself. Benefits are tied to the injury and the employee's ability to work, not to the employment relationship. In Texas, for example, "disability" for income benefits means the inability because of a compensable injury to obtain and retain employment at the pre-injury wage (Tex. Labor Code 401.011(16)), which can continue whether or not the employee still works for you. Ohio's statute provides that an employee who is unable to work or suffers wage loss as the direct result of an impairment from the injury may receive temporary total compensation, and is not eligible if the wage loss is for reasons unrelated to the injury; it expressly replaced the older court-made voluntary abandonment doctrine (Ohio Rev. Code 4123.56(F)).
What the termination can affect, depending on the state:
Ask the carrier how the separation affects the claim before the termination date, not after. Your experience mod reflects what the carrier pays, so a termination that increases wage-loss costs can show up in your premium.
Before the termination, assemble a single file. If the decision is challenged, this is your defense.
Decision documents
Leave and accommodation documents
Payroll and benefits documents
Separation documents
Keep medical information in the separate confidential medical file, not in the personnel file. See our article on workers' comp payroll processing for the pay-side records that support the file.
Most workers' comp retaliation claims start with a manager who did not know the rules and a file that cannot explain the decision. The Workers' Compensation Training & Certification program covers communicating with employees and insurance representatives, benefits and the claims process, medical restrictions and return to work, and injury and employment records. It is online and self-paced with a year of access, team enrollment with a manager progress view for three or more learners, and an optional exam for the Certified Workers' Compensation Administrator designation.
In most states, yes, if the reason is legitimate and unrelated to the claim, such as a documented position elimination or a neutral layoff. What state law prohibits is terminating or discriminating against an employee because they filed or pursued a claim. Employers also have to respect FMLA job restoration rights and ADA accommodation duties, which can apply at the same time. Have counsel review any termination involving an open claim.
Usually not by themselves. Benefits are based on the injury and the employee's ability to work. In Texas, disability means the inability because of the injury to obtain and retain employment at the pre-injury wage, which can continue after separation. Ohio pays temporary total benefits when wage loss is the direct result of the injury and not for unrelated reasons. Medical benefits for the injury continue regardless. Ask the carrier how your state treats it.
It is firing, demoting, threatening or otherwise discriminating against an employee because they filed a claim, tried to file one, hired a lawyer or testified in a proceeding. Most states prohibit it by statute, for example Texas Labor Code 451.001, Florida Statutes 440.205 and New York Workers' Compensation Law 120. Remedies vary by state and can include reinstatement, lost wages and penalties. Timing and inconsistent treatment are the most common evidence.
Yes, if anything is owed. Even after months with no payroll activity, the final check includes earned but unpaid wages, commissions and bonuses, and accrued PTO where state law or your policy requires payout. Deadlines are set by state law and can be as short as the day of discharge, as in California. Workers' comp benefits themselves come from the carrier and are not part of the final check.
Yes. Termination of employment other than for gross misconduct is a qualifying event, generally giving up to 18 months of continuation coverage under federal COBRA for employers with 20 or more employees. Notify the plan administrator within 30 days. If the employee was on FMLA leave and does not return, the qualifying event is the last day of FMLA leave. Smaller employers may be covered by state continuation laws.
Be careful. Under the FMLA, an employee may decline a light-duty job and keep job restoration rights for the rest of their FMLA leave, though they may lose workers' comp wage benefits. After FMLA leave ends, the ADA and state law still apply, and some states treat refusal of suitable work only as a benefits issue. Document the offer, the restrictions and the response, and get counsel's advice before acting.

1-770-410-1219
support@PayrollTrainingCenter.com


