Reviewed by Charlie Bross, Principal · Payroll Training Center
Most return-to-work problems are not caused by bad intentions. They come from a supervisor improvising a light-duty job, payroll not knowing what rate to pay, and nobody checking whether the employee is still on FMLA leave. A written return to work policy fixes that by deciding the questions once, before the next injury, and applying the same answers to everyone.
Many employers have a return-to-work program in practice but no policy document that says what it is. This post walks through the decisions a policy has to make, with emphasis on the pay and leave provisions payroll will be asked to carry out, then gives a complete sample policy you can adapt.
The first decision is who the policy covers. Three common choices:
The ADA allows the first choice, with conditions. The EEOC's enforcement guidance on workers' compensation and the ADA says an employer may recognize a special obligation to employees injured on the job and create light-duty positions for them, and that it need not create a light-duty position for an employee with a disability that is not work-related. But the same guidance says that if an employer reserves light-duty positions for occupational injuries, it must consider reassigning an employee with a non-occupational disability to a vacant reserved position as a reasonable accommodation when there is no other effective accommodation and doing so would not be an undue hardship. The employer cannot claim hardship simply because the position might be needed later for someone injured at work.
Pregnancy needs its own look. The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (42 USC 2000gg-1) requires covered employers to make reasonable accommodations for known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions unless doing so would be an undue hardship, and bars requiring an employee to take leave if another reasonable accommodation can be provided. A light-duty program closed to non-occupational conditions does not settle that obligation. State laws may add more.
Transitional duty works best when it is clearly temporary. The policy should set:
The EEOC guidance supports time limits: if an employer's light-duty positions are only temporary, it does not have to make one permanent for an employee whose occupational injury is a disability; it need only provide a temporary one. What a time limit cannot do is end the conversation. When an assignment expires and the employee still cannot perform the regular job, the ADA interactive process starts (or continues), and options such as reassignment to a vacant position or leave as an accommodation stay on the table. Write that into the policy so supervisors do not treat day 90 as an automatic termination date.
This is the section most policies skip and the one payroll needs most. Decide and write down:
An employee with a work injury is often on FMLA leave, receiving comp benefits and potentially covered by the ADA at the same time. The policy should say plainly that:
Two different federal rules apply:
Workers' comp adds a third channel: work-status reports from the treating provider. The policy should say who receives them, how restrictions reach the supervisor (the restrictions, not the diagnosis), and that medical information is kept in a separate confidential file, not the personnel file.
A policy is only as good as its consistency. Write down:
The text below is a sample policy. Adapt it to your organization, your state's workers' comp, leave and paid-leave laws, and your benefit plans, and have it reviewed by employment counsel before adoption. Bracketed items are choices you must make.
[Company Name] Return-to-Work and Transitional Duty Policy
> Purpose. [Company Name] supports employees in returning to productive work as soon as it is medically appropriate after an injury or illness. This policy describes transitional duty, pay during transitional duty, and how this policy works with leave and benefit programs.
> Scope. This policy applies to [all employees / employees with a work-related injury or illness reported under our workers' compensation program]. Employees with non-work-related conditions [may also be offered transitional duty / should contact Human Resources to discuss available options, including reasonable accommodation and leave]. Nothing in this policy limits any right to reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act or state law.
> Return-to-Work Coordinator. [Title] coordinates return to work. The coordinator receives work-status reports, identifies transitional assignments, issues written offers, communicates with our workers' compensation carrier or administrator, and notifies Payroll of schedule and pay changes.
> Medical Restrictions. Employees must provide work-status reports from their treating provider after each visit that changes their restrictions. Supervisors will receive the restrictions only, not diagnoses. Medical information is kept confidential and separate from personnel files.
> Transitional Duty. When an employee is released with restrictions, the company will try to identify temporary work within those restrictions. Transitional duty may include modified tasks in the employee's own job, a different temporary assignment, or a reduced schedule. Assignments will be offered in writing and will state duties, schedule, location, supervisor, pay rate, start date and review date.
> Duration. Transitional assignments are temporary and normally last no longer than [__] calendar days. The coordinator will review each assignment at least every [__] days or when restrictions change. An extension requires approval by [title]. If an employee cannot return to the regular position when an assignment ends, Human Resources will discuss next steps with the employee, including whether a reasonable accommodation is needed.
> Pay During Transitional Duty. Employees on transitional duty will be paid [their regular rate of pay / the rate for the transitional assignment / their regular rate for the first __ days, then the rate for the transitional assignment]. Nonexempt employees will be paid for all hours worked, including overtime as required by law. Where workers' compensation provides partial wage-loss benefits, those benefits are paid by the carrier, not through payroll, and Payroll will report the employee's actual weekly earnings to the carrier. [Company Name] [does / does not] supplement workers' compensation benefits; any supplement is taxable wages.
> Use of Paid Time Off. Hours missed for medical appointments or because of a reduced schedule may be [unpaid / covered by accrued PTO at the employee's option / covered by accrued PTO as required by company policy, except where law provides otherwise]. While an employee receives workers' compensation wage benefits, the company will not require use of paid leave during FMLA leave.
> Family and Medical Leave. Eligible employees' absence for a qualifying serious health condition, including time away due to a work injury, will be designated as FMLA leave and runs concurrently with workers' compensation and short-term disability. Hours worked on transitional duty do not count as FMLA leave. An employee on FMLA leave may decline transitional duty without losing FMLA protection; declining may affect workers' compensation wage benefits under state law.
> Short-Term Disability. Partial benefits under the company's short-term disability plan during a reduced schedule are governed by the plan document. Payroll will report earnings to the plan administrator as required.
> Benefits. Group health coverage continues during FMLA leave on the same terms as if the employee were working. Employees remain responsible for their share of premiums, which will be [deducted from pay / billed directly] when pay is insufficient. Eligibility for other benefits during transitional duty or leave follows the applicable plan documents and company policy.
> Fitness for Duty. Employees returning to full duty from FMLA leave for their own serious health condition [must / will not be required to] provide a fitness-for-duty certification, as stated in the FMLA designation notice. Other medical inquiries will be limited to what is job-related and consistent with business necessity.
> Declining Transitional Duty. Employees who decline a transitional assignment should tell the coordinator in writing. The company will share the offer and response with its workers' compensation carrier or administrator, which decides any effect on benefits under state law.
> Records. The coordinator keeps offers, responses, restrictions, schedules and earnings reports in the claim or leave file. Medical records are kept confidential.
> Consistent Application. This policy applies equally to all covered employees. Questions go to [title, contact].
> No Contract. This policy does not create a contract of employment or guarantee any particular assignment. [Company Name] may revise it at any time, subject to applicable law.
A policy only works when the coordinator and payroll know how each provision plays out on a real claim. Our return-to-work guide collects related articles on light-duty offers, refusals and FMLA interaction.
The Return-to-Work Training & Certification program teaches the person who will run this policy: modified duty and restrictions, FMLA restoration rights, fitness-for-duty documentation, ADA reasonable accommodation, interaction with workers' comp, and consistent procedures. It is online and self-paced with one year of access, and an optional exam leads to the Certified Return-to-Work Administrator designation. Teams of three or more can enroll with a manager progress view.
At minimum: who is covered, who coordinates, how restrictions are received, how transitional duty is offered and for how long, what it pays, how it coordinates with FMLA, ADA, short-term disability and workers' comp, fitness-for-duty requirements, what happens if an employee declines, and what records are kept. The pay provisions are the ones most often missing, and they are the ones payroll needs to carry the policy out consistently.
Generally yes under the ADA. The EEOC's guidance says an employer may create light-duty positions for employees injured on the job and need not create one for a non-occupational disability. But if the employer reserves light-duty jobs for work injuries, it must consider reassigning an employee with a non-occupational disability to a vacant reserved job as an accommodation when nothing else works. Pregnancy limitations also require separate analysis under the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act.
Yes. EEOC guidance says that if an employer's light-duty positions are temporary, it need only provide a temporary position to an employee whose occupational injury is a disability, not a permanent one. When the time limit runs out, though, the ADA obligation does not end. If the employee still cannot perform the regular job, the employer should continue the interactive process and consider other accommodations, including reassignment or leave.
Federal law does not require it. You may pay the rate of the transitional job, as long as it meets minimum wage and overtime rules, and exempt employees still meet the salary and duties tests. Some employers keep the regular rate for a period to encourage return. State law, union contracts and your own policy may limit your options. Whatever rate you choose, state it in the written offer and report actual earnings to the carrier.
Yes. Under 29 CFR 825.220(d) an employee cannot be required to take a light-duty job instead of FMLA leave, and can decline while keeping FMLA protection until the 12 weeks are used. Declining a suitable job offer may reduce or suspend workers' comp wage benefits under state law, which is the carrier's decision. Send the offer and the response to the carrier or TPA.
No. A policy sets a standard process for transitional duty, but each employee with a disability is entitled to an individualized assessment of reasonable accommodation. Use the policy as the default path and include language that nothing in it limits accommodation rights under the ADA, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act or state law.

1-770-410-1219
support@PayrollTrainingCenter.com


