Reviewed by Charlie Bross, Principal · Payroll Training Center
When an employee comes back from FMLA leave, HR focuses on the job. Payroll has its own list: the pay rate, the raise that went through while they were out, the bonus that was paid in March, three months of missed health premiums, a 401(k) deferral that stopped, and a PTO balance that may or may not have grown. Get these wrong and the employee's first paycheck back becomes the first complaint.
This guide covers the payroll side of a return to work after FMLA, section by section in the order you will meet the issues, with the regulation behind each rule. It ends with a checklist you can run for every returning employee.
For the basics of eligibility and notices, start with our overview of FMLA requirements for employers.
The core rule is in 29 CFR 825.214: on return, the employee is entitled to the same position held when leave began, or an equivalent position with equivalent benefits, pay and other terms and conditions. That holds even if the employee was replaced or the job was restructured during the absence.
29 CFR 825.215(a) defines an equivalent position as one "virtually identical" to the former position in pay, benefits and working conditions, including privileges, perquisites and status. For payroll, "equivalent pay" breaks down into several items you need to check, not just the base rate:
Practical step: before the return date, pull the employee's last pre-leave pay record and compare it field by field with the position they are coming back to. Rate, pay group, shift code, differential codes, department and cost center should all match unless there is a documented, non-leave reason for the change.
If the employee's worksite closed or the job was eliminated for reasons unrelated to the leave, the employee has the same rights they would have had if they had been working (825.215(e)(1)). If everyone at the closed site was transferred, the returning employee transfers on the same terms. Document the business reason, because the burden of showing the change was unrelated to leave falls on the employer.
This is where most payroll errors happen, because raises and bonuses are processed in batches and the employee on leave is not in the room.
Under 29 CFR 825.215(c)(1):
The test is consistency. Pull the policy for non-FMLA leaves (personal leave, non-FMLA medical leave) and apply the same rule.
29 CFR 825.215(c)(2) says equivalent pay includes any bonus or payment, discretionary or non-discretionary, consistent with the raise rule above. Then it sets out the exception that matters most:
Worked example. A plant pays a quarterly perfect-attendance bonus. Its policy counts approved vacation as attendance but counts unpaid personal leave as an absence. An employee takes three weeks of FMLA leave, two of them covered by substituted paid vacation and one unpaid.
Under 825.215(e)(3), the employee must also have the same or an equivalent opportunity for bonuses, profit-sharing and similar payments going forward. Do not leave a returning employee off the next bonus plan because they missed the enrollment meeting.
Group health coverage must be maintained during FMLA leave on the same conditions as if the employee had been working (29 CFR 825.209(a)). The employee keeps paying their share. How that share was collected during leave determines what payroll does on return.
Under 29 CFR 825.210:
Under 825.212(a), coverage can be dropped if the employee's payment is more than 30 days late, but only after written notice mailed at least 15 days before coverage ends. Under 825.212(b), if the employer kept coverage in force by paying the employee's share after a missed payment, it may recover that share.
Recovering the missed share on return is a deduction from wages, so state wage-deduction law applies. Many states require written authorization for this kind of deduction, and federal minimum wage rules can limit deductions that benefit the employer. Get a signed repayment agreement with a schedule, for example over the same number of pay periods as the missed premiums, rather than taking it all from the first check.
Under 825.215(d)(1), benefits resume at the end of leave in the same manner and at the same levels as before, subject to any changes that applied to the whole workforce during the leave, unless the employee elects otherwise. The employee cannot be required to requalify: no new waiting period, no open-enrollment wait, no physical exam for life insurance, including family and dependent coverage.
Even if coverage lapsed because the employee did not pay, 825.212(c) says the employer must still restore equivalent coverage on return without new qualification requirements.
Check each deduction code: medical, dental, vision, FSA, HSA, voluntary life, disability, supplemental policies, union dues, garnishments and loan repayments. Benefits that changed for everyone during leave, such as a new premium rate or plan, apply to the returning employee too (825.209(c), 825.210(a)).
For non-health benefits the employee pays for (supplemental life, disability), 825.215(d)(3) says the employer follows its established policy for other unpaid leaves. Some employers pay the employee's share during leave to avoid a lapse and recover it on return. Under 825.213(b), if the employer chose to maintain those benefits, it can recover only the employee's share of premiums, whether or not the employee returns.
Sometimes the employee does not come back. 29 CFR 825.213(a) lets the employer recover its own share of health premiums paid during unpaid FMLA leave if the employee fails to return after the leave entitlement is exhausted or expires, with exceptions.
The employer may not recover if the employee did not return because of:
If the employee claims a health condition, the employer may require medical certification within 30 days of the request. If certification is not provided in time, the employer may recover 100 percent of the health premiums it paid during unpaid leave.
Points payroll needs to know:
Under 29 CFR 825.215(d)(2), an employee may, but is not entitled to, accrue additional benefits or seniority during unpaid FMLA leave. Benefits accrued before leave began, such as paid vacation, sick or personal leave that was not substituted, must be available on return.
Two consequences for the payroll system:
Also check whether your state's paid sick leave law has its own accrual or reinstatement rules; they apply alongside FMLA.
29 CFR 825.215(d)(4) sets three rules:
For payroll, the immediate task is restarting elective deferrals at the employee's existing election on the first paycheck back, and checking whether the employer match uses a true-up or a per-pay-period formula. If the plan document gives employees a way to make up missed deferrals, follow the plan; if not, do not create one ad hoc.
Under 825.215(d)(5), employees are treated as if they continued to work for purposes of benefit plan changes, except changes that depend on seniority or accrual during the leave.
Run this before the first pay date after return:
Whether the leave was paid or unpaid drives several of these steps; our article on whether FMLA leave is paid covers substitution in more detail. For the broader picture, including fitness-for-duty and workers' comp returns, see our return-to-work guide.
Most return-from-leave errors happen because no one person owns the handoff between leave administration, benefits and payroll. The Return-to-Work Training & Certification program covers FMLA return considerations and restoration rights, fitness-for-duty documentation, coordination with leave administration and consistent procedures, so the person who owns that handoff knows the rules behind it. It is online and self-paced with one year of access and free updates when the law changes, and an optional exam leads to the Certified Return-to-Work Administrator designation.
If the raise was unconditional, such as a cost-of-living or across-the-board increase, yes. The FMLA regulations entitle the employee to it. If the raise depends on seniority, length of service or work performed, the employer applies the same rule it uses for employees on comparable non-FMLA leave. If those employees would get the merit increase, so does the FMLA employee. If they would not, the employer may defer it, provided the policy is applied consistently.
Only a bonus tied to a specific goal, such as hours worked, sales or perfect attendance, that the employee missed because of FMLA leave. Even then, if the employer would pay it to someone on an equivalent non-FMLA leave, such as paid vacation, it must also pay the FMLA employee. Discretionary and non-discretionary bonuses not tied to such a goal are part of equivalent pay. Check how your bonus plan treats other types of leave before denying anything.
If the employer paid the employee's share to keep coverage in force, it may recover that share. Because recovery usually means a wage deduction, follow your state's deduction rules: many require written authorization, and deductions cannot cut into federal minimum wage. A signed repayment agreement spread over several pay periods is the cleanest approach. Do not drop coverage on return or make the employee requalify, even if payments were missed.
The employer may recover its share of health premiums paid during unpaid FMLA leave, unless the employee did not return because of a serious health condition or other circumstances beyond their control. Periods covered by paid leave or workers' comp are excluded. An employee who returns for at least 30 calendar days counts as having returned. Recovery from final pay is allowed only where state wage payment law permits it.
During unpaid FMLA leave, the employee is not entitled to accrue additional benefits or seniority, though the employer may allow it. If PTO is substituted for FMLA leave, it accrues like other paid time under your normal rules. Whatever the employee had accrued before leave began must still be available on return. Treat FMLA leave the same way you treat other unpaid leave, and check any state paid sick leave rules that apply alongside.
Unpaid FMLA leave cannot be treated as a break in service for vesting or eligibility to participate, and an employee on leave on a plan's crediting date is deemed employed on that date. However, unpaid FMLA periods do not have to be counted as credited service for benefit accrual, vesting or eligibility. Payroll's main task on return is restarting deferrals at the existing election and checking the match calculation.

1-770-410-1219
support@PayrollTrainingCenter.com


