Reviewed by Charlie Bross, Principal · Payroll Training Center
Many small employers sign with a professional employer organization (PEO) partly so they can stop thinking about workers' comp. The PEO buys the coverage, deducts the cost from each invoice and handles the carrier. That works until someone gets hurt, an auditor calls, or you decide to leave the PEO and an agent asks for your experience mod. Then the questions come quickly. Whose policy is it? Who files the claim? Whose payroll goes on the audit? Does your claim history follow you?
The answers depend on how the PEO's coverage is written and on your state's PEO statute. This guide covers the structures, who does what when an employee is injured, how payroll and class codes flow, what happens to your experience mod when the PEO relationship ends, and where state law limits the arrangement. For the wider topic, see our workers' comp hub.
Under a PEO agreement, the PEO and your business are co-employers of your worksite employees. The PEO typically runs payroll under its own tax accounts, administers benefits, and takes on some employer obligations by contract. You still direct the work, supervise people every day, and control the workplace where injuries happen.
Workers' comp sits across that line. The PEO's contract usually says the PEO will secure coverage for the worksite employees. But the facts the carrier needs (what people do, how the injury happened, whether light duty is available) come from you. Most problems with PEO workers comp come from each side assuming the other is handling something.
Some state laws spell this out. Ohio's PEO statute, for example, makes the PEO responsible for maintaining coverage, paying premiums and managing claims for its client employers, and requires it to keep each client's classifications, payroll and claims separately and report them to the Bureau of Workers' Compensation under a separate subaccount for each client (Ohio Rev. Code 4125.03). Ohio also gives the client a right to request its own claims, premium and payroll information, and the PEO must answer within 45 days.
There are three common ways a PEO arrangement is covered. Your service agreement should say which one applies, and if it does not, ask.
|
Structure |
Who is the named insured |
What it means for you |
|
Master policy |
The PEO, with clients covered under it |
One policy covers many clients' worksite employees; the carrier must still track payroll and claims by client in most states |
|
Multiple coordinated policies (MCP) |
Each client has its own policy, coordinated by the PEO |
The PEO arranges and administers the policies, but each is issued in the client's name |
|
Client-held policy |
Your business buys its own policy |
The PEO runs payroll but you keep a normal relationship with your own carrier and agent |
On a master policy the PEO is the primary insured and its clients are covered as part of the arrangement. A small employer can benefit from the PEO's purchasing power, but you do not hold the policy, you may not see the policy documents, and your loss information sits inside a much larger account. Ask the PEO for the policy number, the carrier's name and a certificate naming your business.
Some states require client-level policies. Louisiana, for example, requires a separate policy for each client, with payroll for all of the client's employees assigned to the policy in the client's name and the experience modification calculated using the client's own experience (La. R.S. 22:1746). The PEO still administers the program and must supply the insurer with each client's name, federal ID number, class codes, payroll and loss data.
Where state law allows it, a client may keep its own workers' comp policy while using the PEO for payroll and HR. You then have a direct relationship with your carrier, your own audit and your own mod, and the PEO's role is mainly to report accurate payroll by class code to you or your carrier.
An injury happens at your worksite, so the first report starts with you whatever the policy structure.
OSHA recordkeeping is a separate question from who holds the policy. If you obtain employees from an employee leasing service and supervise them day to day, you must record their work-related injuries and illnesses on your OSHA 300 log (29 CFR 1904.31(b)(2)). In a typical PEO arrangement you are the day-to-day supervisor, so the OSHA log is usually yours to keep. Severe-injury reports to OSHA also follow the worksite. Our guide to reporting a workplace injury walks through the employer's first steps.
The wage statement the carrier needs to set benefits comes from payroll records. Under a PEO, those records are the PEO's, so make sure the PEO knows to send the wage statement and that you send any pay the PEO does not process, such as bonuses paid outside its system.
Workers' comp premium is built from payroll by class code, multiplied by rates and adjusted by your experience mod. Under a PEO, the PEO processes the payroll, but the class codes describe your operations.
What to check:
At year end the carrier audits the policy. On a master policy the audit is of the PEO, but the auditor still needs client-level detail in most states, and the PEO will come to you for job descriptions and records. Our guide to the workers' comp premium audit explains what auditors ask for.
The experience modification rate compares your actual losses to the losses expected for businesses of your size and class mix. It typically uses about three years of completed policy data, so claims from your PEO years can affect your premium for years after you leave.
Whether your PEO-era experience follows you depends on how it was reported. Where the carrier reported payroll and claims by client, the rating bureau can calculate a mod for your business alone. NCCI's employee leasing rules approved for Nevada, for example, require the carrier on a master policy to report separate payroll and claims data for each client so that a mod can be calculated for the client on request, and they provide that when the leasing arrangement ends, the client's experience mod applies to the client's future policies. Louisiana's statute similarly bases each client's mod on the client's own experience.
What this means in practice:
Rules differ by state and by rating bureau. NCCI handles experience rating in many states, but several states use their own rating organizations. Ask your agent which bureau rates your business and how it treats PEO experience.
In four states (North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming) employers buy workers' comp from the state fund, not from private carriers. A PEO cannot place you on a private master policy there. In Ohio, as described above, the statute makes the PEO responsible for coverage and premiums but requires client-level reporting to the state bureau. In the other monopolistic states, ask the PEO exactly whose state fund account covers your employees and who files payroll reports with the state.
If you have employees in a monopolistic state and others elsewhere, you may end up with a PEO policy for some states and a state fund account for others. Our guide to monopolistic workers' comp states explains how those funds work.
Other states regulate PEOs through licensing or registration and set rules for how PEO coverage is written and reported. Check your state's workers' compensation agency and insurance department for its PEO rules before you sign or leave.
Before you sign, at renewal, and when you plan to leave, ask:
Return to work is where clients matter most. The PEO and carrier can approve restrictions, but only you know whether you can offer work within them. Agree in writing on who sends modified-duty offers and who tracks the employee's progress.
A PEO handles the paperwork, but your business still controls the workplace, the job descriptions and the return-to-work options. The Workers' Compensation Training & Certification program covers reporting injuries, working with employees and insurance representatives, benefits and the claims process, return to work, and how premiums are determined. It is online and self-paced with a year of access, and an optional exam leads to the Certified Workers' Compensation Administrator designation.
Most PEOs arrange workers' comp for the worksite employees they co-employ, often on a master policy where the PEO is the named insured. Some states require a separate policy for each client, and some allow clients to keep their own policy while the PEO runs payroll. The service agreement should say which structure applies. Ask for a certificate of insurance naming your business so you can prove coverage to customers and regulators.
Under co-employment, the PEO and the client both have employer roles. The PEO usually secures coverage and handles the carrier relationship by contract, while the client directs the work and controls the worksite. State PEO laws define how responsibility is split; Nevada's, for example, applies workers' comp's exclusive remedy protection to the PEO, the client and the client's employees. Check your state's PEO statute and your service agreement for the specifics.
Usually, yes, if the carrier reported payroll and claims at the client level, which many states require. Under NCCI rules approved for Nevada, for example, the client's experience mod applies to its future policies when the leasing arrangement ends, and Louisiana bases each client's mod on its own experience. Ask the PEO for your loss runs and payroll by class code before you leave so your new carrier can rate you correctly.
The employee reports to your supervisor, and you report to the PEO right away using its hotline or portal. The PEO or its carrier then files the first report with the carrier and, where required, the state agency. You still gather the facts at the worksite and decide whether modified duty is available. If you supervise the employees day to day, the OSHA 300 log is usually yours to keep.
Ohio, North Dakota, Washington and Wyoming are monopolistic states, where workers' comp comes only from the state fund (or self-insurance where allowed). A PEO cannot place your employees there on a private master policy. Ohio law makes the PEO responsible for coverage and premiums but requires it to report each client's payroll and claims separately. In the other monopolistic states, ask the PEO whose state account covers your employees.
No. A payroll company processes your payroll under your own tax accounts and may offer a pay-as-you-go workers' comp policy issued in your name. A PEO co-employs your workers and often covers them under its own policy. With a payroll company you keep your own policy, audit and experience mod. With a PEO, the structure depends on the PEO's program and state law.

1-770-410-1219
support@PayrollTrainingCenter.com


