Reviewed by Charlie Bross, Principal · Payroll Training Center
Traditional workers' compensation billing asks a small business to guess. You estimate next year's payroll by class code, pay a deposit based on that estimate, pay installments and then settle up at a year-end audit. Guess low and you get a bill months after the money was spent. Guess high and you have tied up cash all year.
Pay-as-you-go (often called PayGo) changes the timing. Premium is calculated from each actual payroll and drafted as you go, usually through an integration between your payroll provider and your insurance carrier. It is a payment method, not a different kind of policy. The coverage, the rates, the class codes and the audit all stay the same.
This guide explains how pay-as-you-go workers' comp works, what data moves between your payroll provider and the carrier, why the audit still happens and where the numbers most often go wrong. For the basics of how premium is built, see our guide to calculating workers' comp premiums, and for the wider topic, our workers' comp hub.
Workers' comp premium in most states is built on payroll. The basic formula:
Premium = (payroll in a class code ÷ 100) × the rate for that class code, then adjusted by your experience modification (if you have one), schedule credits or debits, and state-specific charges.
Under a traditional plan, the carrier applies that formula to your estimated annual payroll at the start of the policy. Under pay-as-you-go, it applies the formula to each actual payroll:
A worked example. Suppose an office employee in a clerical class rated at $0.20 per $100 of payroll earns $2,000 this period, and a warehouse employee in a class rated at $4.00 per $100 earns $1,800.
|
Employee |
Class |
Payroll |
Rate per $100 |
Premium this payroll |
|
Office |
Clerical |
$2,000 |
$0.20 |
$4.00 |
|
Warehouse |
Warehouse |
$1,800 |
$4.00 |
$72.00 |
|
Total |
|
$3,800 |
|
$76.00 before modifiers |
The rates here are illustrations only; yours are on your policy's information page and vary by state, carrier and class.
Most pay-as-you-go plans still require a down payment at the start of the policy. Carriers describe it as typically lower than under a traditional installment plan, but it is not zero. Ask your agent how yours is calculated.
What the carrier receives depends on the integration. The minimum is gross payroll for the period by state and class code. Many carriers and integrations also look for:
The weak point is the class code. Your carrier assigns class codes to your operations; your payroll system assigns a class code to each employee. If the payroll system's code is wrong, every report and every premium draft is wrong too. Some carriers note that their pay-as-you-go feed receives summarized payroll and not your full registers, quarterly tax returns or subcontractor records, which is one reason the audit is still needed.
When you set up pay-as-you-go, ask your carrier and provider:
Our article on class codes explains how codes are assigned and why getting them right matters.
Pay-as-you-go does not eliminate the premium audit. The standard workers' compensation policy says the premium shown at the start is an estimate and that the final premium is determined after the policy ends using the actual premium basis. It also gives the insurer the right to examine and audit your records, including payroll records. Carriers that offer pay-as-you-go say plainly that they still perform a final audit.
The audit checks what the payroll feed cannot:
What changes with pay-as-you-go is the size of the adjustment. If payroll was reported accurately all year, the audit should produce little or no additional premium. If class codes were wrong, the audit can still produce a significant bill. Our guide to the workers' comp premium audit walks through preparation.
The most expensive mismatch. A warehouse worker coded as clerical underpays premium every payroll, and the audit corrects it all at once. A clerical employee coded into a high-rate class overpays all year. Review your payroll system's class assignments against your policy at renewal and whenever someone changes jobs.
Watch for employees who do two kinds of work. Rules on splitting one employee's payroll between classes are strict, and many rating systems require records showing the split; otherwise the whole payroll may go into the higher-rated class.
Executive officer payroll is often subject to minimum and maximum amounts set by each state, and some states let certain officers or owners elect out of coverage. If your payroll system reports an officer's full salary when a state maximum applies, you overpay. If it reports nothing for an included officer, the audit adds payroll back. Confirm with your agent how your state treats officers and owners and make sure your provider's integration reflects it.
Under the NCCI Basic Manual's payroll rules, the extra pay for overtime can be excluded from premium payroll if your records show overtime pay separately by employee and summarized by class code. Only the premium portion is excluded, not the hours themselves:
If your payroll provider reports total gross wages without separating overtime premium, you pay premium on money you could have excluded. Not every state follows the NCCI rule, and some states run their own rating bureaus with their own manuals; check with your agent for your state.
Under the NCCI rules, premium payroll generally includes commissions, bonuses, holiday, vacation and sick pay, and employee salary reductions for retirement and cafeteria plans. It generally excludes tips, employer contributions to employee benefit plans and severance pay (except pay for time worked or accrued vacation). A payroll system's "gross wages" figure will not always match these rules, so know which earnings codes your provider is reporting.
Reconciliation is what turns pay-as-you-go from a convenience into a control. Monthly or quarterly:
At year-end, run the same check for the full policy period before the auditor arrives. If you find an error, tell your agent and carrier before the audit rather than during it.
Pay-as-you-go makes premium billing easier. It does not change who is responsible for classifying employees correctly, reporting payroll accurately and managing claims. The Workers' Compensation Training & Certification program covers how premiums are determined and how employers can affect them, along with injury reporting, the claims process, return to work and recordkeeping. It is online and self-paced, with a year of access and an optional exam that leads to the Certified Workers' Compensation Administrator designation.
Pay-as-you-go workers' comp is a billing method in which premium is calculated from each actual payroll instead of an annual estimate. Your payroll provider reports wages by class code to your carrier each pay period, the carrier applies your rates, and premium is drafted from your bank account. The coverage, rates and class codes are the same as a traditional policy. Only the payment timing changes, and a down payment is usually still required at the start of the policy.
Yes. The standard policy sets the final premium after the policy ends based on actual payroll and gives the carrier the right to audit your records. Carriers offering pay-as-you-go say they still perform a final audit. The audit checks class codes, payroll totals, subcontractors, officer payroll and exclusions. With accurate reporting during the year the adjustment is usually small, but classification errors can still produce a bill.
Generally yes. Pay-as-you-go relies on payroll data reaching your carrier each pay period, usually through an integration between your provider and the carrier. Not every provider works with every carrier. Before you switch, ask both which integrations they support, which data fields are sent, who maps employees to class codes and how corrections are reported. Some carriers allow manual reporting instead, which puts the work back on you.
The straight-time portion is. Under the NCCI Basic Manual, the extra pay for overtime can be excluded from premium payroll if your records show overtime pay separately by employee and by class. For time-and-a-half recorded as one total, one-third is excluded; for double time, one-half. States with their own rating bureaus may follow different rules, so confirm with your agent, and make sure your provider's feed reports overtime premium separately.
Not by itself. Your rates, class codes and experience modification determine premium; pay-as-you-go changes when you pay it, not how much. It can reduce costs indirectly by avoiding large audit bills you were not prepared for and by avoiding overpaid deposits based on high estimates. Some carriers charge installment fees for pay-as-you-go plans, so compare the total cost with your agent.
The premium drafted for that period will be wrong too. Small errors are often corrected through a later report or at the audit. Systematic errors, like a misclassified employee, build up all year and are corrected in one adjustment at audit time. Reconcile carrier statements against your payroll register by class code monthly or quarterly, and report corrections promptly.

1-770-410-1219
support@PayrollTrainingCenter.com


