search

Outsourced Payroll Doesn't Outsource Workers' Comp: What Small Employers Still Own

10/12/2026

Reviewed by Charlie Bross, Principal · Payroll Training Center

Many small business owners assume workers' comp is handled because payroll is handled. The payroll company calculates the premium, the PEO's name is on the policy, the pay-as-you-go deposit comes out every pay period. Then an employee falls off a ladder on a Thursday afternoon, and the owner discovers that nobody at the provider is going to fill out the injury report, call the doctor's office, offer light duty or answer the adjuster's questions about overtime.

Outsourcing payroll moves the calculation work. It does not move the employer's legal duties. This post sorts out which workers' comp tasks a payroll provider or PEO typically takes on, which ones stay with you no matter who runs payroll, and what one trained person in your office needs to know to cover them.

What Your Payroll Provider or PEO Handles

Arrangements vary, so read your service agreement. In general there are three models.

Payroll service with your own policy

You buy a workers' comp policy from an agent or carrier. The payroll service processes wages and taxes. It may send payroll reports to your carrier, and if you use a pay-as-you-go program, it may calculate and remit each period's premium deposit based on actual payroll by class code.

What the service usually does not do: report injuries, manage claims, choose class codes or represent you at the premium audit.

Pay-as-you-go through the payroll provider

Similar to the above, but the provider has a relationship with the carrier and the premium is billed through payroll. This smooths cash flow and reduces audit surprises, because premium tracks real payroll. It does not change who is the employer for injury reporting.

PEO (co-employment)

A professional employer organization typically puts your employees on its master workers' comp policy, runs payroll, and may offer claims support and safety resources. Even here, the PEO is not on your job site. Your supervisors see the injury first, control the work assignments that make light duty possible, and hold the facts the claim depends on. Most PEO agreements require you to report injuries to the PEO within a short window and to cooperate with return-to-work; missing that window can shift costs back to you under the contract.

Whatever the model, the dividing line is the same: the provider handles money and data; you handle people and facts.

What Stays With You: Injury Report, Light-Duty Offer, Wage Statement, Records

The injury report

You are the one who learns about the injury, so you are the one who starts the clock. That means:

  • Getting the injured employee to appropriate care.
  • Recording what happened, where, when, who saw it and what the employee said.
  • Giving the employee any claim form or notice your state requires.
  • Reporting to your carrier, TPA or PEO within the state deadline.

Our step-by-step guide to reporting a workplace injury covers the details.

The light-duty offer

Only the employer can offer modified work, because only the employer controls the jobs. When the treating provider releases the employee with restrictions, someone in your office needs to decide whether there is real work within those restrictions, put the offer in writing and send a copy to the adjuster. Early return to modified work tends to shorten the time an employee is out, and in many states an unjustified refusal of suitable work can affect wage-loss benefits. That decision is the carrier's under state law, but it starts with your written offer.

The wage statement

Wage-loss benefits in every state are calculated from the employee's pre-injury earnings, usually an average weekly wage built from a look-back period. The adjuster will ask you for a wage statement. Your payroll provider holds the data, but you are the one who knows which numbers belong in it: overtime, second jobs with you, bonuses, tips, the value of employer-provided housing or meals where the state counts them, and periods the employee did not work. Each state defines the look-back period and what counts as wages, so pull the state form from the agency or from our workers' comp state pages rather than sending a generic payroll register.

Pay during the absence

Statutory workers' comp benefits are paid by the carrier and are excluded from the employee's income under IRC 104(a)(1). If you choose to continue full salary or top up the benefit, those employer payments are taxable wages and must run through payroll with withholding. Tell your provider exactly which payments are wages and which are not, or the W-2 will be wrong.

Records

Your provider keeps payroll records. You keep:

  • OSHA records. If you had more than 10 employees at any time during the last calendar year and are not in a partially exempt industry, you must keep the OSHA 300 Log and 301 Incident Report, enter each recordable case within 7 calendar days of learning about it, post the 300A summary from February 1 to April 30, and keep the records for 5 years after the year they cover (29 CFR 1904.29, 1904.32, 1904.33). Employers with 10 or fewer employees are generally exempt from keeping these records, but not from reporting severe injuries.
  • Claim files: the injury report, witness statements, medical work-status forms, light-duty offers and the employee's responses, and correspondence with the adjuster.
  • Certificates of insurance for subcontractors, if you use them, so uninsured subs do not end up on your audit.

Deadlines That Don't Move Because You Outsource

None of these deadlines pause because a third party processes your payroll.

OSHA severe injury reports

Every employer covered by the OSH Act, regardless of size, must report:

  • A work-related fatality within 8 hours.
  • A work-related in-patient hospitalization, amputation or loss of an eye within 24 hours (29 CFR 1904.39).

Your PEO cannot make this call for you unless your agreement specifically says so, and you would still be the employer OSHA cites.

State first reports of injury

Each state sets its own deadline for getting the employer's report to the carrier or the state agency. A few verified examples show how much they differ:

State

Employer deadline

Source

California

Give the employee the DWC-1 claim form within one working day of learning of the injury

Labor Code 5401; Division of Workers' Compensation

Florida

Report to the carrier within 7 days of actual knowledge of the injury

Fla. Stat. 440.185(2)

New York

Report within 10 days when the injury needs treatment beyond first aid or causes lost time beyond the day of injury

NY Workers' Compensation Board

Texas

Report to the carrier by the 8th day after an injury causes more than one day of absence

Tex. Labor Code 409.005

 

These are examples, not a complete list, and states revise forms and electronic filing rules. Check your state agency for the current rule and build a cushion: if your PEO's contract says "report to us within 24 hours," that is your real deadline.

Employee notice periods

States also give employees a window to report injuries to the employer. Florida's is 30 days (Fla. Stat. 440.185(1)). An employee who tells a supervisor in the hallway has usually given notice, so train supervisors to pass every report up the same day.

Premium Audit Surprises From Payroll Data

Your provider's payroll data feeds the annual premium audit, and the audit is where outsourced employers get the biggest surprises. Common ones:

  • Class codes assigned at setup and never revisited. If an office employee started doing deliveries, or a new role was added under the wrong code, the auditor will reclassify the payroll and bill the difference.
  • Overtime reported at full time-and-a-half. Many rating rules exclude the overtime premium portion from workers' comp payroll, but only if your records show it separately. If the provider's report shows total gross pay only, you may pay premium on the premium.
  • Uninsured subcontractors. Payments to subs who cannot produce a certificate of insurance may be added to your payroll at audit.
  • Owner and officer payroll. States have different rules on whether owners and officers are included or can be excluded, and on minimum and maximum payroll amounts for them. Your provider applies whatever was set up; confirm it is right.
  • Pay-as-you-go true-up. Even with pay-as-you-go, the carrier still audits. Differences in class codes or excluded pay show up there.

Before the audit, reconcile your provider's year-end payroll by class code to your quarterly wage reports and W-2 totals, and pull subcontractor certificates. Our workers' comp payroll department checklist walks through the year-end steps.

One Trained In-House Person: What They Need to Know

A small business does not need a risk department. It needs one person, often the office manager or bookkeeper, who knows the workers' comp process for employers well enough to act on the day of an injury and follow through until the employee is back at full duty. That person should be able to:

  1. Explain the reporting chain: who the employee tells, who calls the carrier or PEO, and the deadlines for each step.
  2. Recognize an OSHA-reportable event and make the 8-hour or 24-hour report.
  3. Complete the state injury report and any employee notice or claim form.
  4. Pull a correct wage statement from the provider's data.
  5. Draft a light-duty offer from the doctor's restrictions and coordinate with the supervisor.
  6. Coordinate FMLA and ADA if the injury also triggers leave or accommodation duties.
  7. Track the claim: open items, adjuster contacts, return-to-work dates.
  8. Keep the OSHA log and claim files current and retained.
  9. Prepare for the premium audit: class codes, overtime detail, subcontractor certificates.
  10. Know what the provider does and doesn't do under your contract.

Our workers' comp hub has state-by-state rules and related guides for each of these.

Train the Person Who Owns Workers' Comp in Your Office

The Workers' Compensation Training & Certification program is built for exactly this role. It covers identifying and reporting injuries and occupational illnesses, communicating with employees and insurance representatives, benefits and the claims process, medical restrictions and return to work, safety and injury prevention, how premiums are determined and how employers can affect them, and injury and employment records. It is online and self-paced with a bookmark feature, so it fits around running an office, and you get one year of access with free updates when the law changes. An optional exam leads to the Certified Workers' Compensation Administrator designation, which gives your in-house person a documented credential for the job.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does my PEO handle workers' comp claims for me?

A PEO usually provides the policy and some claims support, but it is not at your workplace. You still have to recognize the injury, get the employee to care, gather the facts, report to the PEO within the contract deadline and offer modified work. Most PEO agreements spell out your reporting window and cooperation duties, and missing them can shift costs to you. Read the workers' comp section of your client service agreement and put its deadline in your injury procedure.

Who reports a workplace injury when payroll is outsourced?

The employer does. A payroll service processes wages and may remit premiums, but it does not report injuries or manage claims unless your contract says so. Each state sets a deadline for the employer's report to the carrier or agency, and OSHA requires every employer to report a fatality within 8 hours and an in-patient hospitalization, amputation or eye loss within 24 hours. Name a person in your office who owns these reports and a backup.

Is pay-as-you-go workers' comp worth it for a small business?

Pay-as-you-go ties premium deposits to actual payroll each pay period, which helps cash flow and usually reduces the size of audit adjustments. It does not eliminate the audit, and it does not fix wrong class codes or missing overtime detail. It works best when someone reviews class code assignments at setup and whenever job duties change. Ask your agent or carrier how the program handles overtime and owner payroll before you sign up.

Do I need an OSHA 300 log if I have only a few employees?

If your company had 10 or fewer employees at all times during the last calendar year, you generally do not have to keep OSHA injury and illness records unless OSHA or the Bureau of Labor Statistics tells you in writing to do so. Some low-hazard industries are also partially exempt. Every covered employer, however small, must still report work-related fatalities, in-patient hospitalizations, amputations and eye losses. State-plan states may have additional rules, so check yours.

Who gives the adjuster the wage statement?

The employer, even when a provider holds the payroll data. The adjuster uses it to calculate the average weekly wage that drives wage-loss benefits. Each state defines the look-back period and what counts as wages, so use your state's form and include overtime, bonuses and other pay the state counts. An incomplete wage statement can lead to underpayment, disputes and penalties, so have the trained person in your office review the provider's report before it goes out.

Can I keep paying an injured employee's salary instead of workers' comp?

Some employers continue pay or top up benefits, but that is not a substitute for reporting the claim. The injury still has to be reported to the carrier within the state deadline. Employer-paid salary continuation is taxable wages and runs through payroll with withholding, while statutory workers' comp benefits are excluded from income. Paying wages off the books to avoid a claim can violate state law and cause problems if the injury gets worse.

PayrollTrainingCenter.com
mailing address
9715 Rod Road Suite A Alpharetta, GA 30022
phone1-770-410-1219 emailsupport@PayrollTrainingCenter.com
Trusted Provider Of
Stay Up To Date
Need Training Or Resources In Other Areas? Try Our Other Training Center Sites:
HR Accounting Banking Mortgage Insurance Financial Services For TPAs Safety
Training By Delivery Format & Subjects Covered:
Special Promotions Online Training Resource Materials SeminarsWebinars All Payroll Subjects
Facebook Copyright PayrollTrainingCenter.com 2026