search

The Cost of Garnishment Errors: Employer Liability and How Training Prevents It

10/22/2026

Reviewed by Charlie Bross, Principal · Payroll Training Center

A wage garnishment turns the employer into a collection agent for someone else's debt. The employer does not owe the money, did not choose the creditor, and earns nothing for the work beyond a small administrative fee where state law allows one. Yet when payroll gets a garnishment wrong, the law often moves the debt onto the employer's own books.

This article walks through where that liability comes from, citing the rules themselves: federal statutes, federal regulations and examples of state law. The last section covers the controls and training that keep a payroll team out of these situations. For the day-to-day process, see our wage garnishment handling hub.

Failure to Withhold: When the Employer Owes the Debt

This is the largest exposure, because it can equal the full amount that should have been taken from the employee's pay.

Child support and other support orders

Federal law requires every state's income withholding law to provide that the employer is liable to the State for any amount the employer fails to withhold from income due an employee under a withholding notice (42 USC 666(b)(6)(C)). Federal regulations require the notice itself to tell the employer that it is liable for the accumulated amount it should have withheld (45 CFR 303.100(e)(1)(vi)). The federal Income Withholding for Support form puts it in plain terms: if you fail to withhold as the IWO directs, you are liable for both the accumulated amount you should have withheld and any penalties set by state or tribal law.

State laws implement the rule in their own words. Minnesota's statute, for example, makes the employer liable to the obligee or the child support agency for any amounts required to be withheld that were not paid, and lets the court enter judgment against the employer for support not withheld or remitted (Minn. Stat. 518A.73).

Note the word accumulated. An IWO that sits unprocessed for six months is six months of support the employer may have to pay from its own funds, often with no realistic way to recover it from an employee who has since left.

Federal agency administrative wage garnishment

When a federal agency issues an administrative wage garnishment order, an employer that fails to comply is liable for any amount it fails to withhold from wages due the employee, plus attorneys' fees, costs and, in the court's discretion, punitive damages (31 USC 3720D(f)).

Creditor garnishments

For court-ordered creditor garnishments, the consequences are set by state law and the writ itself. The usual pattern is that a garnishee employer that ignores the writ or fails to answer on time can face a default. Michigan's court-approved writ form, for example, warns the garnishee that "a default may be entered against you for failure to comply with this order." How large a judgment against the garnishee can be depends on the state, so treat a missed answer deadline as a legal matter, not a payroll correction.

Over-Withholding and Wage-Claim Exposure

Taking too much is also a violation. The federal Consumer Credit Protection Act caps ordinary garnishments at the lesser of 25% of disposable earnings or the amount by which weekly disposable earnings exceed 30 times the federal minimum wage, and caps support withholding at 50% or 60%, plus 5% when arrears are more than 12 weeks old. The Department of Labor's Wage and Hour Division has authority to enforce those limits against employers.

Over-withholding happens in predictable ways:

  • Calculating the limit on gross pay instead of disposable earnings
  • Leaving out a legally required deduction, such as state or local income tax, which overstates disposable earnings
  • Running two creditor garnishments that together exceed the 25% cap
  • Keeping a deduction running after a release or termination
  • Withholding a "catch-up" amount after an unpaid leave

The direct cost is refunding the employee. The indirect cost is that money withheld without authority is, from the employee's point of view, unpaid wages, and state wage payment laws have their own claim processes and remedies that vary by state. A pattern of over-withholding across many employees turns a payroll error into a much larger problem. Our article on multiple garnishments priority covers the calculation that causes most of these errors.

Firing Over One Garnishment: CCPA Section 304

Title III of the CCPA, Section 304, codified at 15 USC 1674, says no employer may discharge an employee because the employee's earnings have been garnished for any one indebtedness. DOL explains that this protection applies regardless of how many levies or proceedings are brought to collect that single debt. A willful violation is a federal crime: the employer may be fined not more than $1,000, imprisoned not more than one year, or both (15 USC 1674(b)).

The federal protection covers one debt. It does not protect an employee with garnishments for two or more separate debts, but state law may go further, and other order types have their own rules:

  • Support orders. Federal law requires states to provide for a fine against any employer that discharges, refuses to employ or disciplines an employee because of a support withholding order (42 USC 666(b)(6)(D)(i)), and the IWO repeats the warning. Illinois, for example, says no payor shall discharge, discipline, refuse to hire or otherwise penalize any obligor because of the duty to withhold income (750 ILCS 28/35(d)).
  • Federal agency wage garnishment. An employer may not discharge, refuse to employ or discipline an individual because of an administrative wage garnishment order. The employee may sue, and the court must award attorneys' fees to a prevailing employee and may order reinstatement, punitive damages and back pay (31 USC 3720D(e)).

The practical lesson: managers should never hear about garnishments as a performance issue. Keep garnishment paperwork in payroll, not in the personnel file, and route any termination of an employee with an active order through HR review.

Late Support Remittance Penalties

Federal law requires the employer to send withheld support to the State Disbursement Unit within 7 business days after the date the amount would have been paid to the employee, and requires states to provide for a fine against an employer that fails to withhold support or to pay it to the SDU (42 USC 666(b)(6)(A)(i) and (D)(ii)). Each state sets its own penalty. Two examples:

  • If a payor knowingly fails to withhold the amount in the notice or to pay withheld amounts to the SDU within 7 business days, it owes a penalty of $100 for each day the amount is not paid after the 7-business-day period expires, up to $10,000 for a failure on one occasion. Failing to pay on time on more than one occasion creates a presumption that the failure was knowing, and the penalty may be collected in a civil action by the obligee or public office (750 ILCS 28/35(a)).
  • An employer that withheld support and intentionally failed to remit it is presumed to be in contempt, and an employer found guilty of contempt may be fined up to $250, in addition to its liability for the unpaid amounts (Minn. Stat. 518A.73).

Note the Illinois detail: the penalty runs on the amount designated in the notice "whether or not withheld by the payor." Holding withheld money in a payroll clearing account until the end of the month is not a cash-management choice; it is the violation.

IRS Levy Non-Compliance and Personal Liability

A notice of levy on wages from the IRS works differently from a garnishment. It is continuous from the date it is first made until the IRS releases it (IRC 6331(e)), and the employee keeps only an exempt amount figured from IRS tables; the rest goes to the IRS.

If the employer fails or refuses to surrender what the levy reaches, IRC 6332(d) applies:

  • Liability for the amount. The person who fails to surrender is liable "in his own person and estate" to the United States for a sum equal to the value of the property not surrendered, but not more than the tax for which the levy was made, plus costs and interest (IRC 6332(d)(1)).
  • A 50% penalty. If the failure is without reasonable cause, the person is also liable for a penalty equal to 50% of the amount recoverable under (d)(1), and none of that penalty is credited against the employee's tax (IRC 6332(d)(2)).

For the duty to surrender, the statute defines "person" to include an officer or employee of a corporation who is under a duty to surrender the property (IRC 6332(f)), which is why levy compliance is a question for whoever signs off on payroll, not only for the company.

The flip side is protection. An employer that honors the levy is discharged from any obligation or liability to the employee and any other person for the amounts surrendered (IRC 6332(e)). Compliance is not just the safer choice; it is the one the law protects.

Error-Prevention Controls and Staff Training

None of these liabilities comes from a complicated legal judgment. They come from routine process failures: an order nobody logged, a release nobody keyed, a deduction calculated on the wrong base, a remittance batched too late, a manager who mentioned the garnishment in a termination meeting. That makes them preventable with controls and trained staff.

Controls that close the common gaps

Risk

Control

Order received but not processed

Single intake point; log every order with date received and deadline

Wrong amount or wrong limit

Written calculation worksheet; second-person review on the first payroll

Late remittance

Remittance calendar tied to each pay date; electronic payments where the SDU offers them

Deduction keeps running after release

Balance ledger; payoff reminders; stop only on a written release or termination

Termination over a garnishment

Confidential payroll file; HR review of terminations for employees with active orders

Missed termination notice

Status-change checklist that triggers the IWO termination section

IRS levy mishandled

Levy procedure that follows the IRS forms and instructions exactly

 

Write the procedure down, assign an owner for each order type, and audit a sample of active orders every quarter. Our list of common payroll mistakes shows how often garnishments appear among them, and our garnishment FAQs answer the quick questions staff ask most.

Why training is the control that makes the others work

Controls only work if the people running them know what a valid order looks like, which limit applies, which state's law governs, and what a release or termination must say. Garnishment work is irregular: a small payroll team may go months between IRS levies and years between medical support notices. That is exactly the kind of task where knowledge fades between uses and errors cluster.

Reduce Garnishment Liability With Certified Staff

The Garnishments & Levies Training & Certification program is built around the failure points in this article. It covers the types of wage garnishment orders, employer duties on receipt, issuing authority and instructions, response and processing deadlines, documentation, child and spousal support withholding, medical support, processing and remitting payments, multiple support orders, employment-status changes, amended or terminated orders and recordkeeping.

The course is online and self-paced with a bookmark feature, includes one year of access to the materials, and comes with free updates when the law changes, so your procedure keeps pace with state amendments. Staff who complete it can take the optional exam to earn the Certified Garnishments & Levies Administrator credential. For payroll departments, team enrollment for three or more learners includes a manager progress view, so you can confirm that everyone who touches a garnishment has finished the training. Set against the liability rules above, trained staff are the control that keeps the rest of your procedure working.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an employer's responsibility for a wage garnishment?

The employer must process a valid order on time, withhold the correct amount within federal and state limits, remit it to the right recipient by the deadline, keep records, notify the sender when employment ends, and not discharge or discipline the employee because of the order. For support orders the employer must also apply the withholding law of the state where the employee principally works. Failures can make the employer liable for amounts it should have withheld, plus state penalties.

Is an employer liable if it fails to withhold child support?

Yes. Federal law requires every state to hold employers liable for any amount they fail to withhold under a support withholding notice, and the IWO says you are liable for the accumulated amount you should have withheld plus any state penalties. Minnesota, for example, lets the court enter judgment against the employer for support not withheld or remitted. Contact the sender if you doubt an order's validity, but do not simply ignore it.

Can an employer fire an employee for having a wage garnishment?

Not for a garnishment for any one debt. Section 304 of the Consumer Credit Protection Act prohibits discharge for that reason, and a willful violation can bring a fine of up to $1,000, up to one year in prison, or both. Federal law also requires states to fine employers that fire or discipline employees because of support withholding, and federal agency wage garnishment carries its own anti-retaliation suit. State laws may protect more broadly.

What is the penalty for not honoring an IRS levy?

Under IRC 6332(d), a person who fails to surrender wages subject to an IRS levy is personally liable for the amount not surrendered, up to the tax owed, plus costs and interest. If the failure is without reasonable cause, a further penalty equal to 50% of that amount applies, and it is not credited against the employee's tax. An employer that honors the levy is discharged from liability to the employee for the amounts paid over.

What happens if we send child support payments late?

Federal law requires remittance to the State Disbursement Unit within 7 business days of payday and requires states to fine employers that fail to pay withheld support. Penalties vary by state. Illinois charges $100 per day after the 7-business-day window, up to $10,000 for one failure, and repeated late payments create a presumption the failure was knowing. Minnesota treats intentional failure to remit as presumed contempt.

What is unlawful wage garnishment by an employer?

Common examples are withholding more than the federal or state limit, deducting under an order that was never validly served or has been released or terminated, deducting extra "catch-up" amounts, and disciplining or firing an employee because of a garnishment. The Wage and Hour Division enforces the federal limits and the discharge protection. State wage payment laws may give employees additional claims for amounts taken without authority.

PayrollTrainingCenter.com
mailing address
9715 Rod Road Suite A Alpharetta, GA 30022
phone1-770-410-1219 emailsupport@PayrollTrainingCenter.com
Trusted Provider Of
Stay Up To Date
Need Training Or Resources In Other Areas? Try Our Other Training Center Sites:
HR Accounting Banking Mortgage Insurance Financial Services For TPAs Safety
Training By Delivery Format & Subjects Covered:
Special Promotions Online Training Resource Materials SeminarsWebinars All Payroll Subjects
Facebook Copyright PayrollTrainingCenter.com 2026